Let’s just be honest…
Once you start making your own coffee mixes, you don’t go back.
Because suddenly your kitchen becomes the coffee shop.
No lines. No prices. No “should I?” debate.
Just jars on a shelf… ready when you are.
Copycat Starbucks Crema Salted Caramel Coffee
👉 https://thisoldbaker.com/copycat-starbucks-crema-salted-caramel-coffee/
This is the one that pulls people in.
Creamy, slightly salty, caramel-rich—and that crema-style finish makes it feel like a real coffee shop drink.
If you start anywhere, start here.
Iced Coffee Mix
👉 https://thisoldbaker.com/iced-coffee-mix/
This one is your warm-weather workhorse.
No brewing ahead. No waiting for coffee to cool.
Just mix, pour over ice, and go.
It’s smooth, refreshing, and exactly what you want when it’s hot out—but honestly? You’ll end up using it year-round because it’s just that easy.
Mexican Mocha Coffee Mix
👉 https://thisoldbaker.com/mexican-mocha-coffee-mix/
This is where things get interesting.
Chocolate, coffee, cinnamon, and a subtle warmth that hits just right.
It’s cozy with a little kick—not spicy, just enough to make you stop and go “okay wait… this is good.”
Perfect for when you want something different without getting complicated.
Hazelnut Coffee Mix
👉 https://thisoldbaker.com/hazelnut-coffee-mix/
Classic, smooth, and just a little nutty.
This is your “everyday but better” coffee.
It’s not flashy. It’s not over-the-top.
It’s just good, reliable, and exactly what you want when you don’t feel like thinking too hard.
Salted Caramel Coffee Mix
👉 https://thisoldbaker.com/salted-caramel-coffee-mix/
This one is pure comfort.
Buttery caramel with that hint of salt that keeps it from being too sweet.
It’s the kind of mix you:
- keep stocked all the time
- reach for on slow mornings
- turn into gifts because everyone loves it
Classic Mocha Coffee Mix
👉 https://thisoldbaker.com/classic-mocha-coffee-mix/
Chocolate + coffee = no explanation needed.
This one leans cozy, rich, and familiar.
Hot, iced, blended—it does it all.
French Vanilla Coffee Mix
👉 https://thisoldbaker.com/french-vanilla-coffee-mix/
If you want a go-to that works anytime, this is it.
Soft, warm vanilla flavor that fits every season.
It’s simple—but in the best way.
Snickerdoodle Coffee Mix
👉 https://thisoldbaker.com/snickerdoodle-coffee-mix/
Cinnamon sugar in coffee form.
It’s warm, nostalgic, and tastes like a fresh cookie sitting next to your cup.
Venetian Coffee Mix
👉 https://thisoldbaker.com/venetian-coffee-mix/
This one feels a little elevated.
Espresso, cocoa, vanilla, and spice come together into something that feels like a café moment—without leaving your kitchen.
The Secret Weapon: Homemade Creamers
👉 https://thisoldbaker.com/how-to-make-85-flavors-of-coffee-creamer/
This is where your coffee bar really comes to life.
Once you’ve got a base creamer, you can create endless variations—caramel, vanilla, seasonal flavors, sugar-free options.
One base. Dozens of options.
Why These Actually Work
These aren’t just “recipes.”
They’re built for real life:
✔ Shelf-stable
✔ Fast (seconds, not minutes)
✔ Flexible (make it sweeter, stronger, creamier)
✔ Repeatable (no guesswork)
Most homemade coffee mixes miss the mark.
These don’t.
This Is How You Build a Coffee Bar at Home
Once you have a few jars?
Everything changes.
You stop asking:
“Should I go get coffee?”
And start asking:
“What do I want today?”
Caramel?
Chocolate?
Iced?
Spiced?
You’ve already got it.
And Yes—These Make the BEST Gifts
Layer them in jars.
Add a simple tag.
Done.
They’re:
- affordable
- practical
- actually used
And that’s the kind of gift people remember.
The Bottom Line
This Old Baker coffee mixes aren’t about copying Starbucks or any other brand of coffee.
They’re about replacing it.
With something simpler.
More affordable.
And already waiting for you in your own kitchen.
Leave a Reply