Go Back Email Link

Easter Egg Base Mix (One Mix = 6 Flavors) With Sugar Free Options

This Old Baker's Easter egg base mix creates a smooth, creamy dough that can be turned into multiple flavors like peanut butter, coconut, cream, and more. It’s an easy, no-bake recipe that saves time, uses simple ingredients, and lets you make a whole variety of homemade Easter candy from one batch.
Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Ingredients
  

  • ½ cup butter softened
  • 1 block 8 oz cream cheese, softened
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • 4 cups powdered sugar (Yes you can use sugar free powdered sugar alternatives) Either mix may need more depending on butter, cream cheese and humidity.

Instructions
 

How to Make the Base

  • In a large bowl, beat butter and cream cheese until smooth and creamy.
  • Add vanilla and mix again.
  • Slowly add powdered sugar, 1 cup at a time, until a thick dough forms.
  • 👉 You’re looking for:
  • Soft but not sticky
  • Holds shape when pressed
  • Easy to roll into balls
  • If it’s too soft → add a little more powdered sugar
  • If it’s too stiff → tiny splash of milk or softened butter

Divide & Conquer (THIS is the magic)

  • Split your dough into six equal portions and place into bowls—each one becomes a different flavor.

🥜 Peanut Butter Eggs (Fan Favorite)

  • 1 portion base
  • ¾ cup peanut butter
  • Mix until smooth.
  • Roll into eggs.
  • 👉 Rich, creamy, Reese’s vibes = guaranteed hit

🥥 Coconut Cream Eggs (Grandma Core)

  • 1 portion base
  • 1½ cups shredded coconut
  • Mix + shape.
  • 👉 These hold shape beautifully and feel “old-school homemade”

🍫 Classic Cream Eggs (Easy Version)

  • 1 portion base (leave plain)
  • Optional: tint a small piece yellow
  • Shape into eggs.
  • 👉 Not gooey like Cadbury, but WAY easier and still viral

🍪 Cookie Dough Eggs (Danger Zone)

  • 1 portion base
  • ¼ cup brown sugar
  • ½ cup mini chocolate chips
  • Mix + shape.
  • 👉 These will disappear first. Every time.

🍓 Strawberry Cream Eggs

  • 1 portion base
  • 2–3 tbsp crushed freeze-dried strawberries OR strawberry extract
  • Mix + shape.
  • 👉 That pink center = scroll stopper content

🍰 Cheesecake Eggs

  • 1 portion base
  • Optional: extra 2 tbsp cream cheese + flavor (lemon, vanilla, etc.)
  • 👉 Softer, richer, bakery-style
  • 🥶 Chill Step (DO NOT SKIP)
  • Place shaped eggs on a lined tray
  • Chill 20–30 minutes
  • 👉 This makes dipping 10x easier

🍫 Chocolate Coating

  • Melt chocolate or candy melts. For ONE full batch (40–60 eggs):
    👉 12–16 oz chocolate (about 2–3 cups chips)

    Break it down:

    Small batch (20–30 eggs): 8–10 oz
    Full batch (40–60 eggs): 12–16 oz
    Large eggs: lean toward the higher end
  • Dip eggs using fork or toothpick
  • Let set on parchment
  • Store in refrigerator.

Notes

  • Tablespoon-sized (standard): ~10 eggs
  • Teaspoon-sized (mini/cute for gifts): ~14–16 eggs
  • Large (Reese’s-size): ~6–8 eggs
Can these be sugar free?  These can be made sugar-free with a powdered sweetener—just add until the dough holds together. Texture will be slightly different, but still delicious.  Dip using regular or sugar free chocolate of your choice
🥶 Storage
  • Fridge: up to 1 week
  • Freezer: up to 2–3 months
Store in an airtight container so they don’t dry out.
🍫 Texture tip (important)
  • Cold = firm, clean bite
  • Room temp = softer, creamier
👉 Both are good—just depends on preference